This Which We Call Body
Jan / Feb 2000
printer version
By Phillip Moffitt
One night a few weeks ago as I watched a group of fellow students
leaving the yoga class we had just attended, I started to reflect
on how the body remembers what it learns. The teacher had taught
an intense, stimulating session on how to elongate the middle and
upper thoracic spine in backbends. Done properly, it can relieve
much of the stress and compression that can occur in the lumbar
spine. My teacher always says that if you want your students to
love you, teach a backbend class, because backbends excite the
nervous system, leaving people feeling invigorated.
So there I was, alert from doing all those backbends, quietly
observing the postures and body movements of a group of animated
students as they walked out of the studio, down the stairs, and
out onto the street. What was so striking was the tendency of many
of them to abandon what they had just learned on their mats regarding
the benefits of an elongated spine. Some held their heads forward
with their upper chests slightly collapsed, or they shortened the
backs of their necks, creating an excess of upper thoracic activity.
In either case they exhibited little lengthening in the area between
the side floating ribs and hips as their legs moved.
There was no denying that much of the body wisdom we had just gained
through hard work in class was simply being abandoned. Of course
once I had made this observation, I immediately became mindful of
my own spine. But even with conscious effort, I was not sure how
well I was allowing my body to integrate what I had just experienced
in class.
The simple truth is that it is quite difficult to integrate new
learning into the body's habituated patterns. What happens more
often than you may realize is that you simply become more skilled
at holding or moving your body in a certain manner in yoga class.
It may look as though you are gaining flexibility, but in reality
much of what you are gaining is limited to that particular posture
and ones similar to it. What doesn't happen in this kind of
"activity-specific" training is an integrative mind-body learning
experience such that your body in motion becomes more balanced and
full of ease.
This activity-specific training is not limited to yoga; it can
occur in dancers, martial artists, athletes of all types, even
professional body workers whose practices emphasize integration.
But it is certainly ironic that it happens in yoga, the very meaning
of which is "union" or "yoking." One of my somatics teachers tells
me that some of her most difficult clients are yoga teachers. It
seems that they learn how to impose stretched positions on their
spines without developing stability and range of motion in all the
parts of the spine involved in movement. As a result these teachers
incur injuries that they repeatedly override; the nervous system
recruits other muscle tissue to protect the injured parts, thereby
creating layers of strain in the body.
Moreover, they resist changing, because it means not having the
same flexibility to demonstrate poses. If some yoga teachers have
this much trouble, it is certainly understandable that you, their
students, would be less than fully trained in integrating yoga into
your habitual patterns of movement.
We are certainly not accustomed to having a yoga teacher say to us
as we leave class, "Be sure and integrate what we just experienced."
But in fact you are not receiving the fruit of the practice unless
you do; you're doing the work, but not reaping the benefits.
To practice hatha yoga in its entirety is to focus on translating
what your body learns in yoga into your overall patterns of standing,
sitting, and walking. The goal is not to achieve some ideal of
perfect movement. The point is to discover how you can move with
ease while working within your own limitations.
One must be realistic; you will inevitably have limitations in your
range of motion. But whatever your range, within it you can achieve
a spacious, relaxed feeling-the kind of freedom that you might
experience in your best moments in yoga class.
This experience of ease in the body is not theoretical. It is
distinct and observable, and has a discernible effect on the quality
of your life. You will be less tense, less tired, and more present
in the body. So not only will you stand straighter, sit more
comfortably, and walk with more fluidity, your experience of the
body will be more enjoyable in general.
Body Imaging
Trying to understand how to integrate what you learn in yoga into
the body in your daily life raises an intriguing question: What is
this which you call body? The answer seems so obvious: I have a
body; you have a body; everyone has a body. But then the question
arises: Are you and your body the same thing? "Well, no," you might
say, "I am that which knows the existence of the body. I live in
it and am completely connected to it, but at best it is only a part
of me, for I'm much more than my body." But what is your relationship
to it? Do you so disidentify with your body that it is simply an
object of pleasure and pain for your mind, which you believe to be
your true Self?
Undoubtedly, you come to hatha yoga to work with the physical
postures, for that is the very definition of the practice. But why
do you choose to work with the body? Is yoga a time-out from the
rest of your life? Is it a kind of body-repair shop, as though your
body was an automobile? Do you direct the body to yoga class because
its health is necessary for the mind's well-being? Do you come to
challenge the body because doing so stimulates your mind?
Many people study yoga without ever consciously considering what
deeper beliefs they hold about the body. It is easy to understand
why this is so, for one does not necessarily need a deeper
understanding to receive many of yoga's benefits.
Yoga relieves stress; it is a respite from the pressures of daily
life and a type of health maintenance and repair program for the
body. But yoga in its complete manifestation is only experienced
when you integrate the practice into your life. Without integration
your yoga practice is limited in its effect; it is merely serving
as a kind of pit stop for replenishing the vehicle you call body
as you race along the fast track of your life.
It takes real effort to keep a yoga practice going outside of class.
This effort requires that you stay mindful of your body at work,
while driving your auto, or talking to your loved ones. It demands
that you maintain a spirit of inquiry into how the body is manifesting
moment to moment. Integrating your "yoga body" and your "daily
life body" requires that you continually explore how to be more at
ease with the body, learn to free it of unnecessary tension, and
allow the yoga principles to shape your regular patterns of movement.
The inner experience of doing this kind of integration work is
known as "being in the body."
Your Body as Teacher
Integrating your yoga body with the body that sits and walks and
does all sorts of other movement is a lot of work. Without having
a view of the body that inspires you to do so, it's hard to stay
focused on your body in daily life. The energy for the work has to
have a motivating source. One such motivating source can be the
purely practical goal of maximizing the health and ease of your
body. For instance, you want to bring the release of tension in
your shoulders that you found in yoga class into the other parts
of your day to help you cope with stress. Although this perspective
is valid, in my experience, it's insufficient to sustain the
attention necessary to fully integrate your yoga body and your
daily life body.
A more powerful motivating force, one that reflects a larger vision,
is a commitment to experiencing the mind and body as a linked,
ever-changing unity. In this point of view your body has as much
wisdom and authority as your mind, so each is treated with respect,
but neither is particularly identified as being you. Your body
becomes your teacher, providing you with feedback as to what your
actual experience is in the moment. For instance, you discover you
are slumping while sitting in a meeting and realize it's because
you don't want to be in the meeting; rather than being present to
the feelings of dissatisfaction, your mind has made your body carry
the weight of the unhappiness. Or you may discover that the reason
you don't maintain length in the spine after backbends is that you
habitually tune out the body; you are not comfortable with how
others judge your body, or you have an old, no longer appropriate
habit of rejecting your own body. In each of these instances, it's
what's happening in your mind that is causing discomfort in your
body. But if you view the mind and body as one, you can change
what's going on in your mind by altering what's going on in your
body.
To embrace this larger view is not easy because it takes courage
to be committed to being fully present in the moment. Keep in mind
that the point isn't to perfect the body; everyone knows that's a
dead-end course because ultimately the body decays and dies. Instead
the idea is to be fully awake to the body, accepting it as it is,
while at the same time not imposing any old patterns of movement
on it.
Since that backbend class, I've worked to keep an awareness of my
middle and upper thoracic spine. For the first couple of days, I
caught myself slightly collapsing in the upper chest when sitting
so that my back would round. Because I still had the sensation in
my body, I could make an adjustment that freed my spine. But after
a few days, I lost the sensation, so all I could do was imagine
what it felt like to have the spine open and free. Doing this felt
frustrating and a little dumb, but I persevered. Gradually, I
started to discover a possibility of movement in that part of my
spine while going about my regular activities.
Last night I went back to class with the same teacher and once
again did backbends. As I pushed up into Urdhva Dhanurasana, the
midsection of my spine opened like a lotus (within my range of
motion, mind you). I wish I could say after this wonderful experience
that I walked out of class with my spine completely free.
Unfortunately, it was the same old struggle, but I was beginning
from a place of more freedom than before.
Phillip Moffitt is the founder and president of the Life Balance
Institute, a nonprofit organization devoted to the study of the
mind-body relationship in both personal growth and organizational
leadership. A yoga instructor and somatic educator, he holds a
black belt in aikido and teaches vipassana meditation at the Turtle
Island Yoga Center in San Rafael, California. He's coauthor of The
Power to Heal (Prentice Hall, 1990).
©2000 Phillip W. Moffitt